82% of Credit Union Members Say Security Drives How They Pay

Fraud is becoming harder for credit unions to stop at precisely the moment members are becoming less willing to tolerate it.

That dynamic is at the center of “Defending the Member: How Credit Unions Are Responding to a New Fraud Landscape,” a PYMNTS Intelligence Credit Union Tracker produced in collaboration with Velera. The report finds that fraud is growing more complex across channels as criminals adopt more sophisticated tactics and institutions expand their digital footprints.

At the same time, member expectations are changing. Consumers expect credit unions to detect threats quickly, communicate clearly and prevent losses before they occur. Security is becoming part of the member experience rather than a function that operates behind the scenes.

For credit unions, that means fraud prevention is no longer solely about limiting losses. It is tied to trust, engagement and long-term member relationships.

Several data points illustrate how fraud is evolving:

82% of credit union members say their payment method choice is primarily influenced by which option feels most secure.

77% of credit unions experienced unauthorized network access incidents during the past year.

56% of credit unions identify cybersecurity, including fraud prevention, as a leading concern, making it the top challenge for the second consecutive year.

The finding that 82% of members prioritize security when choosing payment methods highlights how fraud prevention is moving closer to the center of the member relationship. Consumers view security as part of the value proposition offered by their financial institution. The ability to provide protection without disrupting the payment experience can influence how members engage with accounts, cards and digital channels.

The pressure on credit unions is growing as attacks become more pervasive. More than three-quarters of institutions reported unauthorized network access incidents during the past year, underscoring how fraud risks now extend well beyond individual transactions. The report notes that fraud spans multiple channels and touchpoints, exposing weaknesses created by disconnected systems and fragmented defenses.

Digital growth is contributing to that challenge. As credit unions expand digital services, they simultaneously expand the number of potential entry points available to fraudsters. The result is a larger attack surface that requires institutions to monitor activity across accounts, channels and member interactions rather than focusing on isolated events.

The fact that 56% of credit unions continue to rank cybersecurity as their leading concern reflects how quickly the threat environment is changing. The report points to synthetic identity fraud, AI-enabled scams and coordinated attacks that are becoming more difficult to detect using traditional methods.

To respond, credit unions are adopting real-time analytics, machine learning and integrated fraud management systems capable of identifying suspicious activity earlier in the process. The goal is not only to reduce losses but also to minimize friction for members by intervening before fraud occurs.

The institutions best positioned for the next phase of fraud prevention will be those that can combine visibility across channels with faster decision-making and more effective member communication. Fraud may once have been viewed primarily as an operational risk. Increasingly, however, it is becoming a test of how well credit unions can maintain member trust in a digital-first environment.

As fraud grows more sophisticated, members appear to be sending a clear message. Security is no longer an invisible feature. It is becoming a deciding factor in how consumers choose to pay and whom they trust with their financial lives.

At PYMNTS Intelligence, we work with businesses to uncover insights that fuel intelligent, data-driven discussions on changing customer expectations, a more connected economy and the strategic shifts necessary to achieve outcomes. With rigorous research methodologies and unwavering commitment to objective quality, we offer trusted data to grow your business. As our partner, you’ll have access to our diverse team of PhDs, researchers, data analysts, number crunchers, subject matter veterans and editorial experts.