Wage Slowdown Leaves Gig Work Filling Pay Gaps

Wage growth is easing across the private sector, and the latest Employment Cost Index makes clear the deceleration is no longer a blip.

Private-sector wages and salaries rose 0.7% in the first quarter, according to data released April 30 from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The broader wage measure increased 0.8%, while total compensation reached 0.9%, lifted in part by benefits rather than pay itself.

On a 12-month basis, wages and salaries increased 3.4%, where that annual change had been north of 4% in 2023. After accounting for inflation, that translates into only marginal improvement in purchasing power, underscoring the limits of current wage momentum. In fact, the data shows that inflation-adjusted wages were up a scant 0.1% through the past year.

The ECI is designed to isolate pay changes by holding workforce composition constant, stripping out distortions tied to hiring mix. That design makes the current slowdown a direct reflection of employer pay decisions rather than a statistical artifact.

Wage Growth Slows Across Income Bands

The moderation in wages reflects a broader recalibration by employers. Hiring remains selective, and compensation growth is being managed with greater discipline. The effect is visible across occupational categories, where wage gains have settled into a narrower range than in prior periods.

For households, the distinction between employment and income is becoming more pronounced. Job availability has not weakened in a meaningful way, yet wage progression is not keeping pace with expenses. The consequence is a tighter link between earnings growth and consumption capacity.

Lower- and middle-income workers are more exposed to this pattern. Wage gains at the lower end of the income distribution carry less margin for absorbing increases in housing, food and energy costs. Even modest deceleration in pay growth can translate into measurable pressure on household budgets.

PYMNTS Intelligence data on the Labor Economy provides additional context. Workers earning $50,000 or less annually represent a large segment of the labor force and account for a meaningful share of consumer spending. Within this group, financial sentiment has remained subdued even as job conditions have improved, indicating that wage gains have not translated into stronger financial footing.

Income Gaps Drive Supplemental Earnings

The response to slower wage growth is visible in how workers generate income. Nearly 19.5% of lower-income workers report engaging in regular side work, as the joint research from PYMNTS Intelligence and Ingo Payments finds. The scale of participation suggests that supplemental earnings are becoming a routine feature of household income.

The purpose of that income is direct. More than 40% of these workers use side earnings to cover basic living expenses. This points to a gap between wages and required spending, rather than a discretionary effort to build savings. As we noted in separate coverage this week, savings rates are significantly pressured.

The structure of these earnings matters. Many of these roles are task-based and produce uneven payment flows. Income arrives in smaller increments and at irregular intervals, which can complicate budgeting even when total earnings increase.

Higher-income workers also participate in supplemental work, but their use of that income differs. They are more likely to channel additional earnings into savings or longer-term financial goals, reflecting a wider margin between wages and expenses.

The Employment Cost Index confirms that wage gains are moderating. The PYMNTS Intelligence and Ingo Payments data shows how households are responding. Taken together, they point to an environment where a single 9 to 5 job is no longer sufficient on its own to support financial stability.