A PYMNTS Company

Apple Defends 27% Fee in Compliance with Court Order, Phil Schiller Testifies

 |  May 23, 2024

In a recent courtroom showdown, Apple’s Phil Schiller, stood before US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers to defend Apple’s new 27% fee on purchases made outside its App Store. The move, portrayed as a good-faith effort to adhere to a 2021 court order, has sparked intense scrutiny over its compliance with regulations concerning developer payment options, per Bloomberg.

Schiller, a veteran executive integral to the inception of the App Store, emphasized the company’s commitment to aligning with legal mandates. “We are trying to enable what the law requires,” he stated during the hearing, underscoring Apple’s efforts to navigate regulatory frameworks.

According to Bloomberg, the proceedings, unfolding in Oakland, California, mark a pivotal moment in Apple’s ongoing legal saga, as Judge Gonzalez Rogers deliberates on the company’s adherence to her previous ruling.

The focal point of contention revolves around Apple’s decision to levy a 27% fee, a figure sharply criticized during the hearings. Carson Oliver, Apple’s senior director for business management for the App Store, faced intense questioning regarding the justification for this rate. Despite assertions that Apple engaged economic consulting firms to determine a fair commission rate, Judge Gonzalez Rogers rebuked Oliver for the apparent deviation from the recommended range.

Amidst the legal wrangling, Schiller sought to assuage concerns about the impact on developers, expressing openness to the requirement for links to external payment options. “The world has changed and linking out is being required,” Schiller remarked, acknowledging the evolving landscape of digital commerce. Despite prior reservations about the link-out provision affecting user experience, Schiller emphasized the paramount importance of ensuring a safe solution for consumers.

The hearing sheds light on Apple’s multifaceted defense, with Schiller presenting insights into the decision-making process behind the imposition of the 27% fee. Alongside CEO Tim Cook and Luca Maestri, Schiller outlined the rationale behind the controversial move, highlighting the evolving nature of the digital marketplace.

Source: News Bloomber Laws