Clarifying the Scope of Judicial Review in Competition Inquiries: The Saga of PPI
Antonio Bavasso, Mark Friend, Apr 01, 2010
While early reports suggest that 2009 may well prove to be a good vintage for winemakers in Bordeaux, the same cannot unfortunately be said for the U.K. Competition Commission (“CC”). Indeed, 2009 is likely to be remembered as something of an annus horribilis for the CC, as the year in which it suffered an unprecedented succession of high-profile defeats before the Competition Appeal Tribunal (“CAT”).
The cases involved in these decisions raise several questions about the institutional balance between competition authorities and reviewing courts, all of which have far-reaching implications for the robustness of the entire system of competition enforcement. How far is it open to a court or tribunal to review a competition authority’s findings of fact, as opposed to the conclusions drawn by the authority from findings and judgments made in the light of those conclusions? Where is the line to be drawn between judicial review of the decision-making process and a full appeal on the merits? Has the CAT struck the right balance between allowing the CC, as a specialist competition authority, to exercise its judgment and intervene in markets where adverse effects on competition have been identified, while at the same time holding the CC to account? Is it realistic to require a competition authority such as the CC to conduct a detailed cost/benefit analysis of each element of its remedy proposals in the context of what is necessarily an imprecise and forward-looking exercise, involving qualitative judgments?
Links to Full Content
Featured News
Major App Developers Shun Apple’s New Payment Options, Citing Unfavorable Fees
May 12, 2024 by
CPI
Ex-Contractor Pleads Guilty to Rigging Bids in Wildfire Fuel Services for US Forest Service
May 12, 2024 by
CPI
UK Newspapers Warn Apple Against “Web Eraser” Feature’s Threat to Journalism
May 12, 2024 by
CPI
Microsoft Ordered to Pay $242 Million in Patent Infringement Case
May 12, 2024 by
CPI
UK Antitrust Authority Launches Formal Probe into Olink’s Sale to Thermo Fisher
May 12, 2024 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Ecosystems
May 9, 2024 by
CPI
Mapping Antitrust onto Digital Ecosystems
May 9, 2024 by
CPI
Ecosystems and Competition Law: A Law and Political Economy Approach
May 9, 2024 by
CPI
Ecosystem Theories of Harm: What is Beyond the Buzzword?
May 9, 2024 by
CPI
Open Ecosystems: Benefits, Challenges, and Implications for Antitrust
May 9, 2024 by
CPI