A Perspective on the Whole Foods Decision: Would the Most Important Evidence Please Stand Up?
Michael Bernstein, Deborah Feinstein, Apr 24, 2008
In the old game show, To Tell the Truth, panelists tried to convince the audience that they were the one associated with a particular story. They had to weave facts and details into the story to make it sound like the events had happened to them. The audience had to try to figure out which facts were likely to be consistent with the actual story. At the end, the host asked the real person associated with the story to stand up. Analyzing a merger has many similarities to this old game show. While hopefully no one in a merger analysis is actively trying to mislead, the decision makers must still sort through a plethora of facts to determine which are consistent with a theory that would condemn a merger versus a theory that would clear a merger. This is a particularly difficult exercise in a retail merger. There are no customers to interview and there are no customers documents from which one can glean how they might behave in the event of changes in the competitive environment. Which facts are meaningful and which are simply details that serve only to obscure the story? Which facts should be given weight and which should be ignored? And, how much weight should documentary and testimonial evidence be given as compared to economic evidence? An examination of these issues in the Whole Foods matter shows that what the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the district court thought the evidence showed, and what weight to give various evidence, differed so significantly that they reached entirely different conclusions about the matter.
Featured News
Trump’s Defamation Case Against New York Times Advances in Federal Court
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Musk’s xAI Faces Skeptical US Judges Over California AI Disclosure Law
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Italy Ends Vorwerk Antitrust Probe After Consumer Compensation Deal
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Canada Wins Court Order to Advance Gap, Old Navy Advertising Probe
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Russia Orders Major Retailers to Disclose Food Pricing Data in Antitrust Review
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Labor Market Collusion
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
From Price-Fixing to Wage-Fixing: Are Labor Markets the Next Frontier of Public and Private Competition Law Enforcement?
Nov 19, 2026 by
Giulia Rurali & Carsten Krüger
Damage Estimation and Labor Market Collusion
Nov 19, 2026 by
Louis D. Pape
Recent Developments of Labor Market Collusion in the EU: The Dialogue Between Delivery Hero and Tondela
Nov 19, 2026 by
Catarina Vieira Peres & Rita Ferreira Gomes
Enforcement in Labor Collusion and Monopsony: Trends and Challenges
Nov 19, 2026 by
Leyla Karakas & Anna Meyendorff