A PYMNTS Company

Ex-NFL players’ antitrust claims are royalties claims, says court

 |  June 13, 2012

U.S. District Court Judge Paul A. Magnuson has dismissed an antitrust lawsuit brought by former NFL players Gene Washington, Diron Talbert, and Sean Lumpkin. The ex-players had alleged that the NFL monopolized the market for their images and likenesses.

The court distinguished American Needle from the case at hand by noting that the intellectual property involved here was historical game footage properly collectively owned by the NFL and the teams, not property owned only by the team, such as logos or colors. In addition, the court found that the NFL’s copyright ownership for the footage cannot be considered a restraint of trade.

In sum, the court characterized the plaintiffs’ claims as “[those] for royalties, not claims for antitrust.”

Full content: Court Opinion


Related content: Joint Ventures and the Sherman Act: The Problem Revealed by American Needle and How Best to Address It


Want more news? Subscribe to CPI’s free daily newsletter for more headlines and updates on antitrust developments around the world.