European soccer’s governing body UEFA and its influential club representative organization, European Football Clubs (EFC), face a new antitrust challenge after an association representing smaller teams filed a complaint with the European Commission, alleging that an exclusive partnership gives the continent’s wealthiest clubs disproportionate control over the sport.
The Union of European Clubs (UEC) is asking European Union competition regulators to investigate whether UEFA’s agreement recognizing EFC as the exclusive representative of European clubs violates laws prohibiting anticompetitive arrangements and abuse of market dominance, according to a report by POLITICO.
The complaint adds to mounting scrutiny of how European soccer is governed and whether existing arrangements reinforce the financial and competitive advantages of established clubs at the expense of smaller rivals.
At the center of the dispute is a memorandum of understanding between UEFA and EFC, formerly known as the European Club Association. The agreement, initially signed in 2023 and subsequently extended until 2033, establishes EFC as UEFA’s principal institutional partner for representing professional clubs.
The UEC argues that the arrangement effectively excludes hundreds of clubs from decisions involving tournament participation, competition formats, scheduling and the distribution of billions of euros in revenue.
Dennis Gudasic, the UEC’s general secretary and chief executive of Croatian club Lokomotiva Zagreb, questioned whether the current system provides meaningful representation for the broader European soccer industry, according to POLITICO.
The organization contends that the concentration of influence among prominent clubs, including Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich, risks perpetuating competitive imbalances by allowing established participants to shape the rules governing access to lucrative European tournaments.
Dispute Centers on Governance and Financial Influence
The complaint challenges EFC’s institutional role within UEFA, particularly its influence over the committee responsible for reviewing changes to European club competitions.
According to POLITICO, EFC nominates 16 of the 20 members of UEFA’s Club Competitions Committee, which examines matters including qualification requirements, tournament structures and prize-money allocations.
The UEC argues that this arrangement gives a relatively narrow group of clubs substantial influence over decisions affecting teams throughout Europe.
Financial disparities are another central concern.
Related: EU Warns FIFA Commercial Overhaul Could Violate Competition Law
Research cited in the complaint indicates that approximately 50 clubs have accounted for about 80% of Champions League participation slots since 2000, according to POLITICO. The UEC argues that recurring access to European competition revenue strengthens established clubs while making it increasingly difficult for smaller teams to compete.
The research also highlights the scale of UEFA distributions, with one English club receiving approximately €110 million in European prize money during a single season, an amount comparable to a substantial portion of the annual revenue generated by some domestic rivals.
The UEC maintains that such disparities are not solely the result of sporting performance but are reinforced by governance structures that favor clubs already participating regularly in elite competitions.
EFC, which represents more than 900 clubs, has defended the inclusiveness of its governance arrangements. According to POLITICO, the organization says its members can participate in elections for representatives serving on its board and other governing bodies.
However, the UEC questions whether smaller members possess sufficient voting influence to challenge decisions favored by more powerful clubs.
EU Court Ruling Provides Legal Foundation
The legal challenge draws on a December 2023 judgment by the Court of Justice of the European Union concerning UEFA and FIFA’s restrictions on rival competitions, including the proposed European Super League.
In that decision, the court found that rules requiring prior approval for new competitions must operate under transparent, objective, nondiscriminatory and proportionate conditions.
The UEC argues that similar principles should apply to UEFA’s relationship with organizations representing European clubs.
Miguel Poiares Maduro, a former advocate general at the EU’s highest court and former chairman of FIFA’s governance committee, advised the UEC on the complaint.
Maduro argues that granting a single organization exclusive representative authority while limiting the influence of many clubs raises fundamental questions about fair competition, according to POLITICO.