A PYMNTS Company

Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Lose Bid to Dismiss US DRAM Antitrust Suit

 |  November 16, 2026
Samsung

Samsung Electronics Co., SK Hynix Inc. and Micron Technology Inc. failed to persuade a US federal judge to dismiss an antitrust lawsuit accusing the three memory-chip manufacturers of coordinating production restrictions that allegedly drove up prices for widely used computer components.

    Get the Full Story

    Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.

    Subscribe to our daily newsletter, PYMNTS Today.

    By completing this form, you agree to receive marketing communications from PYMNTS and to the sharing of your information with our sponsor, if applicable, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

    US District Judge Noël Wise in California rejected the companies’ joint motion on Nov. 14, allowing a proposed class-action lawsuit brought by consumers and small businesses to proceed. The ruling found that the plaintiffs had presented sufficiently plausible allegations of an unlawful agreement under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, according to TechPowerUp.

    The decision represents a legal setback for the world’s three leading suppliers of dynamic random-access memory, or DRAM, as the semiconductor industry redirects manufacturing resources toward more profitable products used in artificial intelligence systems.

    The ruling does not establish that the companies violated antitrust laws. Instead, it permits the litigation to advance beyond its initial stage, leaving the allegations to be examined through further court proceedings.

    The lawsuit, filed in June by 17 consumers and small businesses across five US states, alleges that Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron worked in parallel to constrain conventional DRAM production beginning in late 2022.

    Together, the companies accounted for more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, according to market figures cited in the lawsuit and reported by TechPowerUp.

    The plaintiffs contend that the manufacturers reduced output of conventional memory products while directing increasing amounts of production capacity toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, a specialized technology used alongside advanced AI processors.

    That transition allegedly tightened supplies of conventional DRAM, contributing to a 697% increase in prices over an 18-month period, according to the complaint as described by TechPowerUp. The price increase is an allegation presented by the plaintiffs, rather than an independent finding by the court.

    The case highlights growing tensions in the semiconductor supply chain as manufacturers prioritize memory products used in AI infrastructure over components serving traditional personal computers, consumer electronics and other markets.

    According to TechPowerUp, the plaintiffs also cited the companies’ decisions to reduce production of older memory technologies, including DDR3 and DDR4, as evidence supporting their claims.

    Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron argued that their production strategies reflected legitimate commercial decisions made independently in response to changing market conditions.

    The companies also pointed to earlier litigation involving allegations of coordinated DRAM supply restrictions between 2016 and 2018. That case was ultimately rejected by a federal appeals court in 2022, which concluded that similar business strategies among major manufacturers did not, on their own, establish an illegal agreement.

    Wise distinguished the latest lawsuit from the earlier dispute, citing additional allegations involving long-term HBM supply agreements, changes to conventional memory contracts and similar customer-screening procedures.

    According to TechPowerUp’s account of the ruling, the judge considered allegations that Samsung and SK Hynix declined long-term conventional DRAM supply arrangements while the companies expanded commitments to HBM production.

    The court also examined claims that all three manufacturers introduced closely resembling customer-verification requirements in January 2026, including questions about end users, order quantities and underlying demand.

    Micron’s decision to discontinue its Crucial consumer-memory business was another development cited in the complaint, TechPowerUp reported.

    Related: Apple’s DOJ Antitrust Fight Draws Epic, Samsung and Roblox Into Legal Clash

    The defendants maintained that their conduct could be explained by the close attention competitors naturally pay to one another in a highly concentrated industry.

    Wise, however, said the alleged similarities went beyond ordinary competitive observation, comparing the companies’ purported behavior to “hawks flying in formation,” according to the court’s written order.

    The judge’s analysis concerned whether the allegations were sufficient to support further litigation, not whether the plaintiffs had proved an unlawful conspiracy.

    The latest dispute also brings renewed attention to the memory industry’s history of antitrust enforcement.

    According to TechPowerUp, Wise declined to disregard an earlier DRAM price-fixing conspiracy covering the period from 1998 to 2002.

    That investigation resulted in penalties against Samsung and Hynix, while Micron received immunity after cooperating with US authorities.

    The historical conduct was among the circumstances considered in evaluating the current complaint, although previous violations do not establish wrongdoing in the present case.

    The companies’ concentrated market positions are central to the latest litigation. With only a handful of major suppliers controlling most global DRAM production, decisions about factory investment, manufacturing capacity and product allocation can have significant consequences for buyers.

    Still, parallel decisions by competitors are not automatically illegal under US antitrust law. Establishing a violation generally requires evidence of an agreement to restrain competition, rather than merely similar responses to market conditions.

    The three manufacturers must submit their responses to the complaint by Dec. 7, with an initial case management conference scheduled for Jan. 12, 2027, according to TechPowerUp and the federal court’s Nov. 14 order.

    The litigation comes as memory manufacturers confront competing demands from AI infrastructure investment and traditional electronics markets.

    The expansion of HBM manufacturing has become an important strategic priority for leading chipmakers, while the plaintiffs argue that the industry’s shift has contributed to shortages and higher costs for conventional DRAM customers.

    TechPowerUp also reported that SK Hynix’s chief executive expects memory supply constraints to persist through 2030, underscoring concerns about the availability of certain semiconductor products.

    For Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, the immediate consequence is a prolonged legal challenge that could subject their production decisions, customer relationships and competitive strategies to closer examination.

    Source: TechPowerUp