Bundling and Tying: Should Regulators Use the Per Se Approach or the Rule-of-Reason Approach? Lessons from the Economics Literature
Sonia Di Giannatale, Alexander Elbittar, Dec 20, 2012
A firm that practices tying in the United States can be committing a per se violation of the an- titrust law, and it can be also considered a per se violation of the Article 102 of the EC Treaty. However, there is evidence for the use of the rule-of-reason approach in some courts’ decisions in tying cases, such as United States vs. Microsoft in 2001 and the case against Microsoft in the EC in 2004. Therefore, the question of when a tying case should be ruled under the per se approach or under the rule-of-reason approach is valid and has policy implications. This article is written to shed light into what could be the appropriate answer by presenting several lessons that we can learn from the economics literature.
Featured News
Meta Faces $887 Million Italian Privacy Fine Over Access to Android Users’ Photos
Nov 15, 2026 by
CPI
New York Social Media Warning Mandate Challenged in Federal Court
Nov 15, 2026 by
CPI
US Senator Pushes for Review of Nvidia’s ‘Too Big to Fail’ Risks
Nov 15, 2026 by
CPI
EU Escalates Antitrust Case Against Greece’s PPC Over Electricity Pricing
Nov 15, 2026 by
CPI
Consumers Seek to Break Up Paramount-Warner Bros. Merger in New Suit
Nov 15, 2026 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Data Portability
Nov 12, 2026 by
CPI
Mandating Access to a Dominant Platform’s Inferred Data: A Two Scenario Diagnosis
Nov 12, 2026 by
Sean Ennis
Data Portability Between Individual Control and Data Sharing at Scale
Nov 12, 2026 by
Jasper van den Boom & Inge Graef
Information Also Wants to Be Expensive: Data Portability and the Open-Systems Creed
Nov 12, 2026 by
Justin (Gus) Hurwitz
Data Portability’s Cybersecurity Paradox: When Protecting Consumer Data Restricts Competition
Nov 12, 2026 by
Sasha Hondagneu-Messner