R. Hewitt Pate, Apr 24, 2008
Few judgments of the European Court of First Instance (CFI) have attracted as much attention or controversy as the decision in Microsoft Corporation v. European Commission. One aspect of the case dealt with Microsoft´s practice of bundling its own Windows Media Player application with its ubiquitous Windows operating system. The Court upheld a Commission decision that found Microsoft liable under Article 82 and, as a remedy, required Microsoft to produce and market an unbundled version of its operating system called Windows N. But Windows N has failed to sell in the marketplace, and the market position of competing media players has nonetheless grown. The ineffective remedy calls into question the liability analysis that came before it. This article examines possible alternative remedies for technological tying and concludes that no satisfactory remedy was open to the Commission or the Court. A more realistic liability analysis would have been appropriate, and the doctrine of objective justification could have provided a better analytical vehicle for resolving the case. By recognizing that, in the context of the software industry, technological bundling is the paradigm of progress, the Commission and the CFI might have avoided an ineffective and potentially dangerous foray into regulation of software design.
Links to Full Content
Featured News
CMA Appoints Joel Bamford as Executive Director for Mergers
Nov 29, 2023 by
CPI
Alibaba Health’s $1.73 Billion Deal to Boost Online Health Store Services
Nov 28, 2023 by
CPI
Nvidia Faces Global Regulatory Scrutiny Amid Antitrust Investigations
Nov 28, 2023 by
CPI
Meta Plans Appeal Following Judge’s Ruling in Privacy Battle with FTC
Nov 28, 2023 by
CPI
Tiger Woods Voices Discontent Over PGA Tour’s Saudi Agreement
Nov 28, 2023 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Consent Decrees
Nov 15, 2023 by
CPI
Consent Decrees Under the Biden Administration
Nov 15, 2023 by
CPI
The FTC´s Prior Approval Mischief
Nov 15, 2023 by
CPI
Fix-It-First: A Seismic Shift in U.S. Antitrust Agency Approaches to Merger Remedies
Nov 15, 2023 by
CPI
“Shadow” Settlements and the Tunney Act
Nov 15, 2023 by
CPI