Brazil has challenged the European Union’s antitrust investigation into Anglo American Plc’s proposed $500 million sale of its Brazilian nickel operations to China-backed MMG, escalating a dispute over regulatory authority, mineral security and international investment.
Brazil’s foreign ministry sent a letter to the European Commission questioning its jurisdiction over the transaction, according to Reuters reporting published by MINING.COM. The communication challenged European intervention in a deal involving mining assets located in Brazil, Reuters reported, citing two people familiar with the matter who requested anonymity.
The intervention adds a diplomatic dimension to a transaction that has become a test of Europe’s efforts to protect industrial supply chains while Brazil seeks greater control over the development of its mineral resources.
The European Commission is examining whether MMG, which is controlled by Chinese state-owned China Minmetals, could redirect ferronickel shipments from European customers to Chinese steelmakers after acquiring Anglo American’s Brazilian business.
Ferronickel is a key raw material in stainless steel manufacturing, and European regulators are concerned that reduced access to Brazilian supplies could increase production costs for manufacturers across the bloc.
In a September statement of objections, the Commission said the market for low-carbon ferronickel was highly concentrated and that European buyers had limited alternative sources. The regulator warned that the proposed acquisition could weaken competition by giving MMG an incentive to supply affiliated steel producers in China rather than European customers.
A European Commission spokesperson acknowledged receiving communication from Brazilian authorities but declined to elaborate, according to Reuters.
Brazil’s objections reflect broader concerns about the ability of foreign regulators to influence commercial transactions involving strategically important domestic resources.
The country’s principal mining industry association, Ibram, has joined the European regulatory proceedings as an interested third party, according to Reuters.
Pablo Cesario, Ibram’s head of institutional affairs, criticized the European assessment and warned that regulatory intervention could create a precedent for other countries to challenge transactions involving Brazilian assets.
The association is particularly concerned that decisions made outside Brazil could affect domestic employment, investment and industrial development.
Related: MMG Moves to Salvage $500M Anglo Nickel Deal With EU Concessions
Brazil’s own competition authority, Cade, did not oppose the proposed sale, Reuters reported.
The dispute comes as President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s administration seeks to strengthen Brazil’s position in global critical-mineral markets.
The government recently established the National Council for the Industrialization of Critical and Strategic Minerals, known as CIMCE, to coordinate policies concerning resources considered essential to economic development and national security.
Earlier in November, the council designated nickel as a priority mineral, citing its strategic importance and exposure to geopolitical risks.
Nickel is used in stainless steel and certain electric-vehicle batteries, making it increasingly important to industrial supply chains and the transition toward cleaner energy technologies.
Lula had intended to discuss the European investigation with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen during the United Nations climate conference in Turkey, but the meeting did not take place, according to Reuters.
The regulatory standoff has also raised questions about the future of Anglo American’s Brazilian nickel operations.
The London-listed mining company has warned that it could close its Barro Alto and Codemin facilities if European authorities prevent the sale.
In a letter to major ferronickel customers on Nov. 17, Anglo American Chief Executive Duncan Wanblad said the company would place the operations into care and maintenance with the intention of closing them if the transaction were prohibited, according to Reuters.
Anglo American decided in 2024 to withdraw from nickel mining as part of a broader restructuring designed to concentrate investment in businesses it considers strategically important.
The company has indicated that it does not intend to commit additional capital to the Brazilian nickel assets if the sale fails.
Meanwhile, MMG has sought to address European competition concerns by offering commitments to maintain ferronickel deliveries to European buyers.
According to Reuters, the revised proposals include increasing guaranteed annual European supply volumes to 16,000 metric tons from 11,500 tons, alongside stronger contractual assurances and greater pricing flexibility.
Those concessions are intended to demonstrate that European stainless steel producers would retain access to Brazilian ferronickel after the acquisition.
The European Commission has not yet approved the transaction and is expected to reach a decision by Dec. 21.
The dispute highlights the growing tension between national control over natural resources and efforts by major economies to secure supplies of strategically important commodities.
For Europe, the proposed acquisition raises questions about dependence on Chinese-controlled companies for industrial materials. Regulators are examining whether the ownership structure could influence where Brazilian ferronickel is sold.
Source: MINING.COM.