A PYMNTS Company

Tesla, Hertz and Uber Face Antitrust Suit Over $4.2B Electric-Vehicle Deal

 |  November 18, 2026
Tesla earnings

Tesla Inc., Hertz Global Holdings Inc. and Uber Technologies Inc. are facing a federal antitrust lawsuit alleging that their business arrangements helped Tesla undermine competition in the U.S. electric-vehicle market, according to a report by Shattered.io.

    Get the Full Story

    Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.

    Subscribe to our daily newsletter, PYMNTS Today.

    By completing this form, you agree to receive marketing communications from PYMNTS and to the sharing of your information with our sponsor, if applicable, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

    The lawsuit, filed in federal court in California, centers on Hertz’s 2021 announcement that it planned to purchase 100,000 Tesla vehicles in a transaction valued at approximately $4.2 billion. The complaint alleges that government incentives enabled Tesla to supply vehicles to Hertz at economically unsustainable prices, potentially limiting competing automakers’ access to rental-car and ride-hailing markets.

    The allegations, initially reported by Law360 and subsequently examined by Shattered.io, have not been established in court. No judicial finding of wrongdoing by Tesla, Hertz or Uber was identified in the source report.

    Hertz announced its planned Tesla purchase in October 2021 as part of an effort to expand its electric-vehicle rental business. The order represented a significant commercial opportunity for Tesla and placed the automaker’s vehicles in a major rental network.

    According to Shattered.io, the complaint alleges that Tesla benefited from government electric-vehicle incentives in a way that allowed Hertz to acquire Model 3 vehicles at prices below their average variable cost, an economic measure used in evaluating predatory-pricing claims.

    The plaintiffs contend that the arrangement disadvantaged competing electric-vehicle manufacturers by reducing their opportunities to supply vehicles to rental fleets and ride-hailing services.

    Uber’s inclusion broadens the dispute beyond traditional vehicle sales. The allegations suggest that access to transportation platforms could influence competition among manufacturers seeking to establish a presence in commercial electric-vehicle fleets.

    However, Shattered.io reported that publicly available information does not establish the specific contractual terms involving Uber or identify the precise mechanisms through which competitors were allegedly excluded.

    Read more: Tesla Wins UK Supreme Court Ruling to Revive 5G Patent Licensing Case

    The report also noted that the plaintiff’s identity, the case number, the exact filing date and any requested damages had not been independently confirmed in the material it reviewed.

    A central issue is whether Tesla supplied vehicles to Hertz at prices that could constitute unlawful predatory pricing.

    Tesla Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk publicly rejected suggestions that Hertz received preferential pricing when the fleet purchase was announced in 2021.

    According to BBC reporting cited by Shattered.io, Musk said at the time that Tesla would sell vehicles to Hertz on the same pricing terms offered to ordinary consumers.

    Musk also argued that strong demand relative to Tesla’s production capacity reduced the company’s incentive to offer substantial fleet discounts.

    Those statements contrast with the lawsuit’s allegations that government subsidies affected the effective economics of the transaction.

    Shattered.io emphasized that the available reporting does not establish the actual price paid for individual vehicles, whether discounts were applied or how any government incentives were incorporated into the transaction.

    Source: Shattered.io.