Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix and Micron Technology must face a US antitrust lawsuit accusing them of coordinating reductions in memory-chip production to drive up prices, after a federal judge rejected their attempt to dismiss the case, according to Courthouse News Service.
US District Judge Noël Wise ruled that the plaintiffs had presented sufficient allegations to allow the proposed class action to proceed, raising questions about whether the world’s dominant memory-chip manufacturers independently adjusted production or worked together to restrict supply.
The lawsuit focuses on dynamic random access memory, or DRAM, a semiconductor component widely used in smartphones, personal computers and data-center servers. The plaintiffs allege that the three companies deliberately reduced conventional DRAM output while shifting manufacturing capacity toward higher-margin memory products used in artificial intelligence applications.
According to Courthouse News Service, the alleged supply restrictions contributed to DRAM price increases of as much as 700% over a four-year period, placing additional financial pressure on consumers and businesses that depend on electronics containing the chips.
The complaint describes a series of production reductions beginning in 2022, when weakening demand and falling prices prompted major manufacturers to scale back output. SK Hynix began cutting production, followed by Micron and Samsung, according to the report.
As demand for AI infrastructure accelerated in 2023, the manufacturers increasingly prioritized high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, a specialized technology used in advanced AI processors. These products generally command higher profit margins than conventional DRAM, providing chipmakers with a commercial incentive to redirect investment and manufacturing resources.
The plaintiffs contend that the companies continued limiting conventional DRAM production even as market conditions improved, contributing to tighter supplies and higher prices. They argue that the manufacturers’ similar production strategies suggest potential coordination rather than independent business decisions.
Related: Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Lose Bid to Dismiss US DRAM Antitrust Suit
According to Courthouse News Service, the complaint alleges that the companies passed up opportunities to generate hundreds of millions or billions of dollars in additional annual operating profits by maintaining restrictions on conventional DRAM output.
Wise determined that the allegations were sufficient to support a plausible antitrust claim at this stage of the proceedings. Although the companies may have independently pursued similar strategies in response to market conditions, the judge found that the plaintiffs were not required to rule out every lawful explanation before advancing their case.
The ruling does not establish that Samsung, SK Hynix or Micron engaged in illegal conduct. The plaintiffs must still provide evidence supporting their allegations as the litigation progresses.
The case also highlights the concentration of the global memory-chip industry. Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron collectively control approximately 91% of worldwide DRAM sales, according to figures cited by Courthouse News Service.
The plaintiffs argue that this market concentration, combined with the substantial financial and technological barriers to semiconductor manufacturing, makes it difficult for smaller competitors to offset production reductions by the industry’s largest suppliers.
Building advanced semiconductor fabrication facilities requires significant capital investment and specialized manufacturing capabilities, limiting how quickly additional supply can enter the market when prices increase.
The lawsuit also references a previous DRAM price-fixing conspiracy involving major memory-chip manufacturers between 1998 and 2002. According to Courthouse News Service, Samsung and Hynix faced substantial penalties following a US Department of Justice investigation, while Micron received immunity after cooperating with authorities.
The plaintiffs cite that earlier case as part of their argument concerning the companies’ alleged conduct, although the previous violations do not establish wrongdoing in the current dispute.
The latest litigation comes as semiconductor manufacturers allocate increasing resources to AI-related technologies, reshaping production priorities across the memory-chip industry. Demand for specialized memory used in AI accelerators has encouraged companies to invest in products offering higher profitability than conventional chips.
Source: Courthouse News Service