A PYMNTS Company

Senators Move to Strip Major League Baseball of Century-Old Antitrust Protection

 |  November 22, 2026
Baseball

A bipartisan effort in the U.S. Senate is seeking to eliminate Major League Baseball’s longstanding exemption from federal antitrust laws, potentially reshaping the legal framework governing the sport’s commercial operations and competitive practices.

    Get the Full Story

    Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.

    Subscribe to our daily newsletter, PYMNTS Today.

    By completing this form, you agree to receive marketing communications from PYMNTS and to the sharing of your information with our sponsor, if applicable, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

    Sen. Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, introduced the Competition in Professional Baseball Act, with Republican Sen. Mike Lee joining as a cosponsor, according to a Nov. 20 report by Traders Union, citing information from the Senate Judiciary Committee.

    The legislation would repeal a legal protection that has distinguished professional baseball from other major U.S. sports leagues for more than a century. Its supporters argue that the exemption gives MLB an unfair advantage by shielding certain aspects of its operations from federal competition laws.

    Durbin has characterized the exemption as a mechanism that permits baseball to operate as a legally protected monopoly. He has also challenged the judicial reasoning behind the protection, pointing to criticism of the original Supreme Court ruling that established baseball’s exceptional treatment under antitrust law, according to Traders Union.

    The proposal represents a renewed attempt to address a legal arrangement that has remained controversial despite decades of changes in professional sports, labor relations and the commercial structure of baseball.

    Antitrust Reform Could Alter Baseball’s Competitive Landscape

    Unlike other major professional sports organizations, MLB benefits from a judicially established exemption that limits the application of certain federal antitrust restrictions to its business activities.

    Removing that protection could expose more of the league’s operations to legal challenges under competition law, potentially affecting how MLB structures commercial relationships and exercises authority over professional baseball.

    The proposed legislation seeks to establish a more consistent regulatory approach across professional sports by eliminating baseball’s special legal status.

    According to the Senate Judiciary Committee information cited by Traders Union, Durbin’s initiative is intended to address the competitive consequences of MLB’s exemption rather than simply modify the league’s existing regulatory obligations.

    The involvement of Lee, a Republican, gives the proposal bipartisan sponsorship, although its prospects for passage remain uncertain.

    Minor League Labor Practices Draw Congressional Attention

    The latest legislative effort follows several years of congressional examination of MLB’s treatment of minor league players.

    While serving as chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee during the Biden administration, Durbin investigated whether baseball’s antitrust exemption adversely affected labor-market competition and employment conditions within the minor league system.

    In June 2022, Durbin contacted Advocates for Minor Leaguers to examine the relationship between the exemption and competition for baseball labor. A subsequent inquiry was directed to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred in July of that year, Traders Union reported.

    Those investigations formed part of the broader scrutiny surrounding minor league employment practices before MLB recognized the unionization of minor league players under the Major League Baseball Players Association in September 2022.

    The recognition represented a significant development in labor relations, giving minor league players a formal collective bargaining framework within professional baseball.

    Congressional concerns continued after union recognition.

    In November 2023, Durbin and other senators questioned Manfred about MLB’s efforts to secure broad exemptions from federal wage-and-hour requirements while the league was negotiating a collective bargaining agreement covering minor league players.

    Durbin subsequently introduced the Fair Ball Act, a separate legislative initiative addressing those labor-related concerns, according to Traders Union.

    Congressional Debate Extends Beyond Labor Rights

    The proposed repeal highlights a broader question about whether baseball should retain legal protections that are unavailable to other professional sports businesses.

    Supporters of removing the exemption contend that the existing framework limits competitive accountability and allows MLB to maintain an unusually privileged position under federal law.

    The legislation would not, by itself, establish that MLB has violated antitrust rules. Instead, it would remove the special protection that currently limits certain legal challenges against the league.

    That distinction could prove important as lawmakers consider the potential implications for MLB’s commercial structure, relationships with affiliated organizations and treatment of workers.

    The renewed legislative push also demonstrates how congressional scrutiny of baseball has expanded beyond player compensation to encompass the league’s broader market position.