Fiona Scott Morton, Dec 20, 2013
This article lays out the economics of competition between branded and generic pharmaceuticals and its welfare consequences. I explain the logic behind so-called “pay-for-delay” or “reverse payments” in the context of the current IP environment where weak (probabilistic) patents are frequently granted by the PTO. The article goes on to relate the Supreme Court decision in Activis to these concepts. I argue that the “scope of a patent” is closely related to its probability of being valid. !e Supreme Court dissenting opinion states that IP owners should be allowed to operate within the scope of the patent. For a very weak patent, that might be a very limited scope and bring the dissent into agreement with the majority opinion that a weak patent owner should not be allowed to create market power where the patent did not grant it. However, the dissenting opinion closes with a rejection of using the concept of probabilistic patents in legal analysis.
Featured News
Italy Ends Vorwerk Antitrust Probe After Consumer Compensation Deal
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Canada Wins Court Order to Advance Gap, Old Navy Advertising Probe
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
Russia Orders Major Retailers to Disclose Food Pricing Data in Antitrust Review
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
UK Court Confirms Government Demand for Access to Apple’s Encrypted Data
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
UK Competition Watchdog Probes Into OCS’s £3.1 Billion Mitie Deal
Nov 18, 2026 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Labor Market Collusion
Nov 19, 2026 by
CPI
From Price-Fixing to Wage-Fixing: Are Labor Markets the Next Frontier of Public and Private Competition Law Enforcement?
Nov 19, 2026 by
Giulia Rurali & Carsten Krüger
Damage Estimation and Labor Market Collusion
Nov 19, 2026 by
Louis D. Pape
Recent Developments of Labor Market Collusion in the EU: The Dialogue Between Delivery Hero and Tondela
Nov 19, 2026 by
Catarina Vieira Peres & Rita Ferreira Gomes
Enforcement in Labor Collusion and Monopsony: Trends and Challenges
Nov 19, 2026 by
Leyla Karakas & Anna Meyendorff