A PYMNTS Company

CFTC Loses Emergency Bid to Block New York Enforcement Against Kalshi

 |  November 22, 2026
CFTC agentic AI

A federal judge has rejected an emergency request by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to prevent New York authorities from pursuing legal action against prediction-market operator Kalshi, marking another setback for the regulator in a growing dispute over oversight of event-based trading contracts.

    Get the Full Story

    Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.

    Subscribe to our daily newsletter, PYMNTS Today.

    By completing this form, you agree to receive marketing communications from PYMNTS and to the sharing of your information with our sponsor, if applicable, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

    U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield in Manhattan ruled Friday that the CFTC had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of succeeding on its argument that federal commodities law prevents states from regulating Kalshi’s activities, according to Reuters.

    The decision allows New York Attorney General Letitia James to continue pursuing allegations that Kalshi has operated in violation of state gambling laws, as federal and state authorities contest which regulatory framework governs prediction markets.

    The CFTC argues that contracts offered by Kalshi qualify as swaps under federal law and therefore fall within the agency’s exclusive jurisdiction. New York officials contend that the company’s products constitute gambling activities requiring authorization from the New York State Gaming Commission.

    According to Reuters, James alleges that Kalshi operated without the required state gaming license and that its products expose consumers to risks associated with gambling addiction and financial harm.

    The emergency request followed a ruling Thursday by U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick, who ordered New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi returned to state court. The case was originally filed July 31.

    Read more: Kalshi Challenges Illinois Sports Betting Tax as Prediction Market Jurisdiction Fight Escalates

    The CFTC sought immediate intervention after the transfer, warning that New York could resume enforcement proceedings against the company, Reuters reported.

    Schofield declined to issue the requested temporary order, leaving the state’s case free to proceed while the broader jurisdictional dispute remains unresolved.

    The legal confrontation reflects growing tensions between federal derivatives oversight and state gambling regulations as prediction markets expand their offerings tied to sports, elections and other events.

    Kalshi operates a federally regulated exchange that allows customers to buy and sell contracts based on the outcomes of specified events. The CFTC maintains that these products are financial derivatives governed by federal commodities legislation, rather than traditional gambling products subject to state licensing requirements.

    State regulators have challenged that interpretation, arguing that federal registration does not automatically exempt companies from laws governing gambling within their borders.

    The dispute has produced conflicting federal appellate rulings. Three appeals courts have determined that states may regulate Kalshi, while another ruled that New Jersey could not enforce its restrictions against the company, according to Reuters.

    Source: Reuters