Posted by Social Science Research Network
The End is Near For the Per Se Rule in Criminal Sherman Act Cases
By Robert Connolly (Law Office of Robert Connoilly)
What do “progressive” Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor and “textualist” Justice Neil Gorsuch have in common? To quote one commentator, “they are on a mission to restore criminal defendants’ constitutional rights:”
In November, the two justices teamed up to champion Sixth Amendment safeguards against notoriously flawed forensic analysis. Weeks later, they came together to attack policing for profit, endorsing Eighth Amendment protections against civil forfeiture. And on Monday, the two joined forces once again to stick up for the right to a trial by jury when the government seeks to impose crippling fines in the form of criminal restitution.
The per se jury instruction in criminal Sherman Act trials will also fall. In a per se case, the court is the initial fact-finder, deciding whether the agreement violated the Sherman Act. If the court determines the indictment alleges a per se violation the jury then only decides whether the charged agreement existed and whether the defendant joined the agreement. Justices Gorsuch and Sotomayor will extend their “right to a jury” advocacy, and gather a majority to hold that: 1) the per se rule is a substantive rule of law, which only Congress, not the Supreme Court can create; and 2) this substantive per se rule improperly takes away the defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to have the jury be the fact finder regarding whether the agreement charged in a Sherman Act indictment actually was a restraint of trade.
Featured News
Court Order Temporarily Halts U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Layoffs
Feb 16, 2025 by
CPI
Nokia Poised to Gain EU Approval for $2.3 Billion Infinera Acquisition
Feb 16, 2025 by
CPI
Turkey Fines Frito-Lay in Antitrust Crackdown
Feb 16, 2025 by
CPI
Advances Bill to Strengthen Antitrust Enforcement Through AI
Feb 16, 2025 by
CPI
Intel Faces Potential Breakup as Broadcom and TSMC Explore Deals
Feb 16, 2025 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – International Criminal Enforcement
Jan 23, 2025 by
CPI
The Antitrust Division’s Recent Work to Combat International Cartels
Jan 23, 2025 by
Emma Burnham & Benjamin Christenson
Information Sharing: The New Frontier of U.S. Antitrust Enforcement
Jan 23, 2025 by
Brian P. Quinn, Casey Kovarik & Michael Tubach
The Key Role of Guidelines on Exchanges of Information Among Competitors and the Divergent Transatlantic Paths
Jan 23, 2025 by
Rosa Abrantes-Metz & Albert Metz
Leniency, Whistleblowers, and Compliance
Jan 23, 2025 by
Richard Powers, Tara O’Malley & Cory Gordon