Millennials are often discussed as one consumer generation, but the way they earn their income tells a more complicated story. This generation is in its 30s and 40s, when careers and major household costs compete for the same paycheck. Yet the cohort’s work lives are split almost evenly between those with fixed salaries and those earning hourly pay, with many relying on contracts, gig platforms or commissions.
That divide shapes more than a job title. It affects how predictable a paycheck is, how much income a worker brings home, how heavily credit card debt weighs on a personal budget and which financial products are likely to help.
“The Millennial Consumer: How They Shop, Bank, Pay and Adopt Technology” is a PYMNTS Intelligence exclusive series, profiling U.S. consumers born roughly between 1981 and 1996. The series draws on data from proprietary surveys, including some conducted regularly since 2020. The research is designed for payments and financial services professionals and covers financial well-being, work, income, shopping, payments, technology, AI adoption and small business ownership. Survey findings are weighted to reflect the U.S. population represented by each study.
This installment focuses on work and employment, where the data reveals one of the clearest dividing lines within the generation.
Millennials’ pay structures reveal a generation divided by income and financial stability
Only 42% of employed millennials receive a fixed salary. Nearly the same share, 40%, makes an hourly wage. Another 8% earn money through contract or consulting fees, 6% earn income through gig platforms and 4% rely primarily on commission-based pay.
That mix challenges the familiar picture of a midcareer worker moving steadily up a salaried career ladder. For a large share of millennials, income can depend on scheduled hours, available shifts, completed projects, customer demand or sales. Warehouse workers, delivery drivers, hotel and restaurant employees, caregivers, contractors and commission-based workers may share a birth-year range, but their cash flow can look very different from that of a salaried office worker.
Variable pay undermines financial stability
Pay structure can influence nearly every part of a consumer’s financial routine. A regular salary makes it easier to align recurring bills with deposits and plan transfers into savings. By contrast, hourly, contract and gig earnings can change from one pay period to the next. Even when yearly earnings cover routine expenses, a short week at work or a poorly timed bill can create a gap.
The income data shows how large that gap can become. PYMNTS Intelligence defines Labor Economy millennials in this analysis as hourly, gig, seasonal or shift-based workers earning no more than $25 an hour and typically less than $50,000 a year. The average annual income for these millennials is roughly $25,500. Salaried millennials average $87,500, more than three times as much. The average across all millennials is $75,000.
Millennial income gaps contribute to credit disparities
The difference carries directly into credit. Labor Economy millennials are more than twice as likely to report a subprime credit score as salaried millennials, at 31% compared with 14%. Their average credit score is 644, versus 701 for salaried peers.
Credit card balances also show why the context in which millennials earn income is important. Labor Economy millennials carry an average outstanding credit card balance of $5,587, slightly less than the $6,596 held by salaried millennials. As a share of income, however, those balances equal 22% for Labor Economy workers and just 8% for salaried workers. A smaller balance can create a much heavier burden when the paycheck behind it is smaller or less predictable.
The same pattern appears with monthly repayments. Thirty-nine percent of Labor Economy millennial cardholders always or usually carry a credit card balance from one month to the next. Among salaried millennials, the share is 18%. That difference can lead to more interest charges and less bandwidth to handle an emergency, especially for workers whose hours or assignments can change.
Financial products must reflect how millennials are paid
For banks, card issuers and payment providers, age-based marketing tends to miss much of this picture. Two millennials may use the same phone, shop through the same apps and prefer the same digital payment methods, but need different financial-support products and tools.
Financial products built around a steady salary often fit poorly with workers earning variable income. Useful options could include faster access to earned funds, flexible payment dates, clearer cash-flow alerts, and savings tools that adjust to changing deposits, and credit decisions that account for consistent employment history even when weekly earnings fluctuate.
The work and employment findings point to a broader lesson. Millennials have plenty in common as consumers, but their sources and rhythms of income can separate them more sharply than age does. Financial providers that recognize this split can design products around the way employers pay consumers, rather than the year they were born.
Read More
PYMNTS Intelligence is the leading provider of information on the consumer trends driving innovation in consumer finance, digital payments and financial inclusion. To stay up to date, subscribe to our newsletters and read our in-depth reports.
