Consumers put more outings on debit cards over the summer and spent less per purchase, against a backdrop where average utility payments climbed.
“People went out more often, but they spent less each time,” Max Spivakovsky, senior director of global payments risk management at SoFi Tech Solutions, told PYMNTS.
According to the company’s Q3 Debit Spend Index, the number of transactions in the experiences category rose 12.9% from the second quarter, while the average charge fell 4.5%. With more purchases, total spending in the category still rose 7.8%. Utilities recorded increases on both measures. There were 10.8% more payments, and the average payment rose 8.9%, lifting total utility spending by 20.7%. The index draws on anonymized debit transactions processed through the company’s platform.
Asked how banks can help customers prepare for predictable expenses heading into the holiday season, Spivakovsky pointed to seasonal patterns in the Q3 data. Back-to-school spending in the index rose about 80% from July to August, and the average utility payment rose every month from June through September. He said a banking app could use a customer’s own history to flag costs like these in June or July before the charges land. “We can always baseline against very specific time periods,” he said.
Spivakovsky said banks “have to watch the relationship between the volume and the ticket size inside very specific categories.” At restaurants, for example, the average charge fell 3.4% from the previous quarter.
A customer making more purchases at smaller amounts may be budgeting carefully. A drop in the number of purchases could signal financial strain or that the customer is using the card less, he said. A bank could show customers how much they have spent on dining so far that month, giving them a figure to work with before they make another purchase.
From Recurring Charges to Checkout
Recurring bills showed one of the widest gaps between growth in dollars and growth in transactions. Spending rose 9.7% on 1.3% more charges. Telecom spending rose 18.1%, with the average telecom payment up 6.5%. When a card is already on file, a price increase can go unnoticed because there is no checkout step.
Spivakovsky said a banking app should show each recurring charge by merchant and amount, alongside what the customer paid in previous months. If a subscription charge goes up, he advised, “the app should notify the end consumer before the next billing cycle.” That would give the customer time to review the service before another payment comes out of the account.
Card-on-file accounted for 27% of debit transactions in the third quarter, up from 25% in the second quarter.
“The risk models today have to account for that,” Spivakovsky said of the different patterns banks see in online and in-person payments. A customer paying with a smartwatch they use every day gives the bank a familiar device to assess. An online purchase from a new device at a merchant the customer has never used gives the bank less history to work with. Spivakovsky said the industry is moving toward checking device and behavioral signals in the background, with an additional verification step only when a transaction warrants closer scrutiny.
Watch the full interview with SoFi Tech Solutions’ Max Spivakovsky to learn about how:
- Consumers made more debit purchases on outings while spending less per transaction across most experience categories.
- Utility spending rose on more and larger payments, while higher prices drove most of the growth in recurring charges.
- Back-to-school spending jumped about 80% from July to August, a predictable pattern banks can use to help customers plan ahead as the holidays approach.