Visa: New Fraud Dispute Rules Will Save Merchants ‘Billions’

Visa building

Visa says it has made it easier for merchants to fight so-called “friendly fraud.”

    Get the Full Story

    Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.

    yesSubscribe to our daily newsletter, PYMNTS Today.

    By completing this form, you agree to receive marketing communications from PYMNTS and to the sharing of your information with our sponsor, if applicable, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

    The payments giant on Thursday (Sept. 28) announced an update to its dispute process for friendly fraud or first-party fraud, for card-not-present transactions.

    “This change could save small businesses over a billion dollars in losses globally over the next five years, in turn benefitting the entire ecosystem of consumers and merchants,” the company said in a news release.

    According to the release, the rule change offers merchants more ways to show a disputed charge is valid and authorized, helping them keep their money while protecting legitimate cardholder transactions.

    As PYMNTS has written, the term “friendly fraud” — also known as “first party fraud” — originally referred to parents discovering their kids had charged purchases their cards and then disputing those charges.

    Since then, it has evolved to something more nebulous, with bad actors — or just customers with buyer’s remorse — disputing legitimate transactions, getting the charges reversed and holding onto their purchases.

    The impact of this type of fraud can devastate small businesses, Visa said in the release, quoting Brooklyn-based fitness studio owner Kaseedee Pilarz, who said the rule change will be a “gamechanger” for her business.

    “I have been in tough situations where legitimate membership charges have been disputed. If I lose the dispute, not only do I lose the membership fee, I also get a penalty,” Pilarz said. “That can be the difference between making payroll or not. This change will help ensure I have a fair shot during those disputes.”

    Visa Chief Risk Officer Paul Fabara noted in the release that the change is part of Visa’s overall fraud-fighting strategy. He added that the company was still committed to “zero-liability” for its members for unauthorized transactions.

    Friendly fraud is just one piece of a larger fraud puzzle. PYMNTS Intelligence found, based on a survey of 200 executives at America’s largest banks, that fraud has risen by 43% at financial institutions (FIs) compared to 2022, with the average cost of fraud jumping by 65% for FIs with assets of $5 billion or more.

    “Misuse of account information remains the leading source of fraud, accounting for 38% of fraudulent transactions,” PYMNTS wrote recently. “Notably, digital wallets like Samsung Pay, Google Pay and Apple Pay, as well as same-day automated clearing house (ACH) and regular ACH payments, have also seen significant increases in fraud rates since 2022.”