Credit unions already count some of the people they’re trying to win as primary customers among their members. Better rewards would make 39% of members who bank mainly elsewhere more likely to choose a credit union as their primary financial institution, according to PYMNTS Intelligence and Velera’s “The Rewards Gap: Turning Member Interest Into Growth.”
Among all consumers whose primary institution was outside the credit union sector, 32% said better rewards or cash back would make them more likely to choose a credit union for their main account. The broader group includes people who already belong to a credit union. Their response rate was 7 percentage points higher than the broader group’s.
Lower rates or fees were the most frequently cited reason to consider a credit union among consumers who bank mainly outside the sector. At 34%, they ranked 2 points ahead of better rewards or cash back. Small to mid-sized businesses outside the credit union system also cited better rewards. Thirty percent said they were a reason to consider a credit union.
Among younger consumers whose primary institution was elsewhere, 37% of Gen Z consumers and 36% of millennials said better rewards could influence their choice. For credit unions looking to attract younger consumers, those figures put rewards among the features worth discussing when someone is deciding where to keep a main account.
Rewards Already Enter the Card Decision
Credit union members weigh incentives in a decision they make more often. Forty-four percent cited better incentives, including cash back, as a factor in choosing which card to use. Among consumers with multiple cards overall, 40% cited incentives, 30% cited lower interest rates or fees and 22% cited higher credit limits.
Members who carry and use several cards have room to make that choice purchase by purchase. Six in 10 credit union members who use multiple cards said they do so to maximize rewards or perks. A member might use a credit union card for groceries or gas and still have their paycheck deposited and their bills paid from an account at another institution.
The findings gives credit unions two ways to gauge how members respond to a rewards offer. Card spending shows whether members are putting more purchases on the credit union’s card. Direct deposits and recurring bill payments show whether those members are also bringing over the banking they’ve been doing elsewhere.