Retail has long worked from the straightforward assumption that customers who visit more often and spend more each trip deserve the most attention.
That logic still explains part of consumer behavior, but the underlying economics are becoming harder to read.
A shopper can generate impressive sales volume while carrying lower margins, higher servicing costs or weaker long-term value.
PYMNTS Intelligence data suggests that consumer caution, alongside evolving payment preferences and increasingly fragmented shopping patterns are complicating how retailers define their most valuable customers.
Consumer restraint has become more nuanced in recent months.
The PYMNTS Intelligence report “The New Checkout: Crimped Consumers Lean Into Online Retail and Digital Wallets” showed that financially strained consumers remain active participants in retail spending even while changing how and where they transact.
Advertisement: Scroll to Continue
Consumers under high financial stress reported larger average retail transaction values than lower-stress consumers in purchasing activity, despite facing tighter household conditions. High-stress consumers averaged $111 on their latest retail transaction versus $88 among lower-stress consumers. Online, the gap widened further, with stressed consumers averaging $169 versus $96.
That pattern creates a challenge for merchants relying on basket size as shorthand for customer quality.
Higher spend increasingly arrives with economic trade-offs. Promotional dependency can compress merchandise margins. Flexible payment structures introduce financing and servicing costs. Fulfillment decisions matter more when consumers concentrate spending into fewer transactions and favor digital channels that carry different operating economics.
As a result, the customer producing the largest order may also require the deepest discount, the most expensive delivery path or the most incentive funding. By extension, revenue increasingly needs to be evaluated alongside acquisition cost, payment behavior and fulfillment efficiency.
The Same Customer Can Behave Premium in One Channel and Value-Driven in Another
Traditional segmentation assumed relatively stable consumer identities. That assumption is weakening.
PYMNTS Intelligence data indicated financially stressed consumers increasingly separate where they shop from how they shop. Consumers experiencing higher financial stress were more likely to shift grocery purchasing online and showed stronger engagement with channels offering convenience and price visibility.
Merchant selection also diverged across channels.
Among grocery shoppers under high financial stress, 56% made their latest grocery purchase at Walmart compared with half of lower-stress consumers. In physical retail, financially stressed shoppers also showed greater concentration toward value-oriented formats, including Dollar Tree. Online behavior became even more segmented, as financially stressed consumers were materially less likely to purchase through Amazon and nearly three times more likely to buy from Target relative to lower-stress shoppers.
The read-across is that consumers are optimizing differently depending on context.
A household may pursue convenience online, seek promotional intensity in stores and reserve discretionary purchases for selected merchants. The same customer can therefore appear affluent in one channel and highly price sensitive elsewhere.
For retailers, channel migration varies by category, urgency and payment flexibility.
Retailers May Need New Definitions of a Good Customer
The evolving customer scorecard is likely to place greater emphasis on payment behavior and retention efficiency.
That’s especially true among young shoppers and households under financial pressure. Digital wallet use continues to expand across retail transactions, while wallet experiences increasingly include embedded installment options and budgeting tools.
The report found that 15% of consumers used digital wallets for their most recent retail purchase, a 50% increase from earlier measurements. Among Generation Z consumers, usage rose to 36%.
Separate PYMNTS Intelligence on installment behavior has continued to show that buy now, pay later (BNPL) usage is extending beyond occasional discretionary purchases into more routine household spending patterns, and credit card installments are rapidly gaining ground.
Payment choice increasingly signals customer quality.
A retailer assessing customer value may need to examine repeat purchase rates adjusted for incentive intensity, payment mix, return behavior, digital engagement and contribution margin. Retention becomes more meaningful when paired with signals that show whether future purchases are likely to remain economically productive.
Retail’s next, and evolving, iteration of customer measurement may therefore ask a different question. Not who spends the most, but who continues spending in ways that remain sustainable for the household and the merchant.
For all PYMNTS digital transformation coverage, subscribe to the daily Digital Transformation Newsletter.
